Just before Christmas my graphics tablet finally broke down on me after 3-4 years. It was a Wacom Graphire 3 A6 size. It wasn’t top of the range but it was a beauty to work with. Never the less it was time for a change but the question was which one should I buy?
The most obvious and typical answer is “Get a Wacom Intuous.” Yes, they are the ones to supposedly get but they are costly, what’s more there seems to be some new players in the tablet field so the question remained “Which one shall I get?”
To get an answer I started scoping out tablet reviews and trying to find out more about them but to be honest the knowledge on tablets is pretty lame:
1.)Most design professionals use tablets yet the reviews on graphic tablets are pretty slim and generic. Its either written by an amateur with no specific user experience or a professional who just gives a general overview.
2.) Most reviews focus on buying your first tablet which was pretty useless for me, I already have one and know how to use it. I wanted some in-depth ideas about buying my second one as a designer.
3.)Designers buy a tablet and use it for 3-5 years. We tend to use only one or two models at a time at the most and therefore we rarely get user experience on using different ones. With this in mind we don’t actually know the difference between one tablet and the next.
4.)The tablet is a tool in which we can’t really measure it’s results. Its a drawing tool but yet it doesn’t have any visual effect on our work. So does it really matter which one you get?
Anyway enough blubbering, here’s what I found out in general before and after buying a new one which may help you to decide when buying yours. This is a comparison and user guide based on Wacom, other tablets and my old graphire
There are a number of factors to consider whether its your first time buying or not:
Sturdiness
consumables
price
size
is it for professional use or private use
We all know about wacom so here’s what you need to know about the others:
Trust, Genius and a few others all sell tablets which are notable. They even claim to have better pressure sensitivity then the wacom and based on amateur reviews they seem to be worth the money (less then half price of a wacom). By no means are they crap but are they as good. I found out that each company actually sells the same tablet in a re-branded format. It’s Aiptek who actually make the tablets amongst other electronics.
Before buying :
Wacom VS others: Sturdiness
One important factor was me was sturdiness. I drop my tablet at least once a week and luckily my old graphire just kept on going, it was actually pretty amazing. After it did finally break, I managed to rewire it and it worked for another year! This alone scored points for Wacom but what about the other tablets.
The other brand tablets were all pretty slim and possibly weak in build. This was off putting for me. I know your not suppose to drop them but I do, so for me Wacom won this round. I could afford to pay more for a sturdy tablet that would not break quickly. I wasn’t sure if the others were capable of the same.
If you are however more careful then me then other tablets are worth considering. They have a whole price range.
Consumables:
Wacoms don’t need any other power supply other then the usb cord. The pen doesn’t need batteries either so there are no other costs apart from nibs (revelation below in “after buying”).
The other brand tablets do need batteries for the pens, so be warned that you will be forking out more every so often for a battery. Re-chargables are a good idea but it is never the less a consumable.
Price:
Price is a big factor but you can make the most of it and get the best tablet for your money. The other tablets are considerably cheaper then Wacom making them very tempting. Although reviews were amateur, they were mostly good experiences and noted as good buys. They all seemed to work well and a bad review was very rare.
If your on a low budget then the other tablets are worth considering but if you really want a Wacom then you can go for an older 2nd hand model which are all very good. Just because there an older model it doesn’t necessarily mean its outdated. It will work and do the same job as the new tablets.
If you’ve got a high budget and you want top of the range then Wacom it is. The size of the tablet will also effect the price range so read on.
Size:
This is a funny factor, whatever brand tablet you use. I was under the impression that the bigger tablets were in some way better then the small ones but despite maybe an extra button or feature they are in fact the same.
It makes no visual difference on your work whether you use a bigger or smaller tablet. The tablet size is actually only a personal preference.
Some like bigger tablets so it feels like your drawing on a A4 sheet of paper. It requires longer strokes and moving your arm/hand much more. I however find that the smaller tablets are much better. Everything is only a hand twitch away allowing me to work faster.
Big tablet users swear by the big sizes and likewise so do the smaller tablet users, so which one do you buy?
The answer is to be very careful in your selection of tablet size as a first time or 2nd time user.
If its your first time then the tablet size you buy will pretty much be the one you’ll always want in the future as you will get used to its spacing and layout. Its not a rule that you have to use the same size forever but you will notice the difference if you buy a different size and it will take some getting use to.
If its your 2nd one then buying a tablet which is a different size to the one you previously had will also take some getting use to. If you want a bigger one then don’t make a huge leap from A6 to A4 as it may very well be a wrong decision when you finally use it. It’ll make a huge difference in your workflow. What was only a flick away is now a whole arm movement.
My Graphire was A6 and my new tablet is an A6 wide. The slight difference has an effect which of course you will get use to but you may find that your preferred your old size tablet instead whether it was bigger or smaller.
Which size to get?
One that suits your budget
One your comfortable drawing on. If you predominantly draw of A4 and its essential for you to do so on the computer then you may prefer a larger tablet.
Medium size tablet is the best all rounder.
Note: Tablets are bigger then the paper size. A6 is the drawable area whilst the tablet is at least another inch bigger allround.
Personal or private use?
I found quite a revelation with this factor. If its for private use then any tablet will pretty much do. Weigh up your options above then pick one best suited.
If its for professional use then consider the above and then consider this.
Are you a digital painter, graphic designer or something else.
The only real sector in which a wacom has great value is digital painting. The features, spec and visual results are actually only notable for them. They’ll see the real effect a wacom has.
If your a graphic designer or something similar the Wacom is very good but you could easily use an older model or another tablet.
Which range?
After all my research I decided on a Wacom. The sturdiness and relaibility was really the wining factor for me.
The next question though was which one.
They have the:
bamboo (entry level, for fun)
Graphire (mid range all rounder) (now discontinued I think)
Intuos (high end for design related businesses)
Cintiq (top dollar!)
Cintiq was out of the question, I can’t afford it! 
Bamboo – Seemed a little amateur
Graphire – Had great experience with it but essentially wanted an upgrade
Intuos – Was the the one I wanted but then again the question arises….which one.
Intuos 1,2,3,4
They’ve all had rave reviews and pretty much hold their price, even the older ones. 1 and 2 were out of the question as I did want an upgrade. So the questions was 3 or 4.
I wanted one brand new and went for the the A6 (which is A6 wide as standard) Intuos 4.
User experience:
The box was beautiful
. So nice that I didn’t want to open it. After doing so the tablet itself looks great as well. All shiny and scratch free I didn’t want to touch it but I couldn’t resist. After a month or so of usage here’s my final review of the tablet and which one you should buy.
Wacom Intous 4 pros:
-Looks great
-Handles both left and right hand users
-Has several shortcut buttons which are all programmable
-Has a precision button to create presise detailed strokes
-Has an optional submenu button which you can program dozens of functions.
-Comes with 12 different nibs.
-Has an IPOD wheel with another 4 programmable functions (nice for zooming in and out).
-Has a pen stand which doubles as a nib holder and mini wrench tool.
Cons:
-The new INTUOS 4 tablets DO HAVE CONSUMABLES. Unlike my old graphire and other old
intuos tablets, the nibs on the intuos 4 run down really quickly. My old one lasted 3-4 years this one will last 3-6 months dependant on usage. You do get 12 different nibs to hold you down though.
- New surface- The old tablets had a plastic screen which was a little slippery but user able. The new ones have done away with the screen and use a rough paper like texture (hence the nibs wearing). It does feel great but at the same time I instantly knew the nibs were going to wear quickly which made the feature a bit apprehensive.
Final decision: which one should you get!
Whether your a first time, private user or on a budget then to be completely honest it won’t really matter which one you get. They’ll all do the job pretty well, either way you wont know the difference unless you’ve used a particular tablet before (regularly).
Don’t be put off of an older wacom, a lower range wacom or even another brand tablet, you won’t be missing out much. (You may even get more)
If your a professional then the same goes as the above EXCEPT:
1.)Painters – You probably will see the difference and appreciate the features of a wacom, even more so with the new intuos 4. If your on a budget then the Intuos 3 is just as good as a pick without the intuos4 cons and some of its pro features but still a great buy.
2.)Graphic Designers – Main benefits for graphic designers are the new buttons of the Intuos 4. They come in handy and really help to speed up work flow. If your like me having to press Ctrl+Alt+Delete every minute then you’ll know what I mean. It makes the keyboard slightly more redundant and the tablet itself has that Wacom seal of approval.
If on a budget and also don’t want the hassle of new nibs then the old intuos range or even the graphire will do the job ( graphire now taken over by Bamboo business). They both have a couple of buttons and worth the investment just as much as the new intuos.
3.) Professional but on a really tight budget!!!! Try and checkout the bamboo! If an old graphire can do the job then I imagine that a new bamboo will do just as much. (justified by the new bamboo business range I saw today).
Hope this helps and if anyone has an aiptek, i’d love to hear what its like.